HIP DROP TACKLES: Prendergast decision shows why World Rugby has to give clarity

The exoneration of Irish flyhalf Sam Prendergast by a disciplinary committee this week for a hip-drop tackle has raised so many questions and has been met with disbelief, uncertainty and a broad silence from World Rugby.
Prendergast tackled Fijian captain Peseli Yato during the Nations’ Championship match between Ireland and Fiji - in a manner that fitted every single definition of a Hip Drop tackle - and while the referee, television match officials and others didn’t take any action, he was cited by the match commissioner after the game.
Advertisement
Yato had to leave the field with an ankle injury due to the tackle - the same type that World Rugby has highlighted and proclaimed to be illegal.
The same type of tackle serves as examples on World Rugby’s website and is virtually identical to what Prendergast executed, and was expected to bring a ban.
But it wasn’t surprising that Prendergast got off - even though the disciplinary committee released a statement confirming this but provided absolutely no reasons why he was exonerated.
VAGUE STATEMENT
All the statement said was the following, “Sam Prendergast (Ireland) appeared before an independent Disciplinary Committee on Tuesday 17 November, having been cited for an alleged act of foul play contrary to Law 9.13 during the Nations Championship match between Ireland and Fiji on Saturday 14 November.
“The Committee was Mike Hamlin (Chair) - England, Wayne Erickson - Australia and Becky Essex - England. Having heard detailed evidence from Sam Prendergast and submissions made by Derek Hegarty and Andy Farrell, the Committee unanimously determined that the player had, to the required standard, proved that the citing should be dismissed.
“Detailed findings of facts and reasons for the Committee’s decision will be set out in its written judgment.”
That’s it - only that he had proved the citing should be dismissed. No hint as to a reason why, no reasoning given and a vague reference to the facts and reasons to be set out in a written judgement.
But unfortunately that is simply not good enough.
When the governing body of the sport makes a massive effort - in their own words - to protect player safety - and says they will come down hard on anyone who transgresses - and then when such an incident happens, it gets swept aside, surely the public has to be given a more detailed explanation than “wait for the written judgement.”
WORLD RUGBY NEEDS TO GIVE CLARITY
World Rugby needs to decide - when is a hip drop tackle a hip drop tackle and when is a knee drop tackle a knee drop tackle? Rugby is a dynamic game made up of collisions and it is fluid. To make such a sweeping change to the laws and then not enforcing it helps nobody.
To allow Prendergast to get off means there is now precedent and by that precedent, what now constitutes a hip drop tackle in the modern game? Is anyone sure? If a tackle virtually identical to the examples posted by World Rugby doesn’t meet the standard then what does?
At the recent World Rugby conference coaches spent three hours reviewing examples of hip drop tackles - only Ireland and France were not present - and all agreed to what constituted a hip drop tackle.
For those still unsure, World Rugby has defined a Hip Drop tackle as:
Hip-drop tackle (World Rugby Law 9.13):
WHEN A BALL CARRIER:
is grasped and tackled from the side or behind, and;
the tackler swings round or through the ball carrier, and/or;
drops their hips/body weight down on to the legs or lower limbs of the ball carrier as they are brought to ground.
Have a look at Prendergast’s tackle again, and it is a classical definition of the exact thing that World Rugby wants to outlaw. The citing commissioner felt it was a citable offence - which meets the red card threshold, but Prendergast is free to play.
WAS THE CITING COMMISSIONER WRONG?
So the question is - if the citing commissioner is wrong, and a tackle that looks like what World Rugby is trying to outlaw results in an injury and shouldn’t be sanctioned - then where are we exactly and what are we trying to get out of the game?
While a lot of the focus has been on Rassie Erasmus’ ban, he did correctly predict that Prendergast would be exonerated and his questions on his assertion of 17 knee drop tackles that went unpunished has yet to be answered by World Rugby.
"We are in the northern hemisphere," Erasmus said. "I think there is going to be a technicality and he is going to play.
"We all thought it's an immediate red card. Everybody watched the game live because that's exactly what they said the hip-drop tackle is," he said.
"I swear I'm not moaning. I'm just trying to give you a perspective of somebody who comes and plays, for example, in France or in Ireland."
World Rugby seriously can’t expect the average fan to understand what the implications of their law changes are, if coaches can’t agree. If the top coaches in the world spent hours analysing clips and then it is ignored on the field of play, everyone loses.
The law was brought in to curb serious injuries that occur from these types of tackles but like any law, unless it is implemented properly, it isn’t worth the paper it is written on.
Rugby needs clarity. The game is tough enough for officials to make over 200 decisions in a fast-moving game without more grey areas. For that reason World Rugby needs to give an answer.
Or their silence will speak volumes for those who don’t understand.
Advertisement
