TALKING POINT: Rassie points out the elephant in the room, ignoring it won't make it go away

Springbok coach Rassie Erasmus’ latest comments regarding knee-drop tackles and the influence of the television match official on matches has ignited a firestorm up north and is likely to place a lot of extra pressure on his side as they head into the test against Ireland on Saturday.
But while social media discourse is buzzing and there are a number of northern hemisphere pundits calling for action against Erasmus for his comments, and a number even calling for a ban for him speaking out, they all miss the fundamental problem that rugby has and never seems ready to deal with.
Advertisement
The press conference of his team announcement for the Ireland match was never going to be the right forum to raise these issues, yet there is clearly a lot of frustration from the Springbok camp on a lot of issues, and World Rugby has only themselves to blame for this.
Coaches are expected to swallow a lot - and to not utter a word in reaction. World Rugby, on the other hand, keeps making laws and changes to the game, those that are directly affecting the way referees ref the game, and then are astounded when things go wrong.
Nobody blames a referee for missing something in the game, but if Erasmus is to be believed and there were 16 drop knee tackles - a tackle World Rugby made a big song and dance about coming down hard on, then he is right to be frustrated.
MENTIONING MATCH-FIXING WAS WRONG
What isn’t right is to insinuate that there might be match-fixing involved. Referees get a lot right and wrong, and on Friday night against France, the Boks were not the better side on the field, didn’t use their chances and ended up on the wrong side of the result. But you got the sense that this issue has been building for a long time now. The travesty of justice against Jan-Hendrik Wessels – who was given a nine week ban without clear evidence on an allegation he had grabbed a Connacht players’ testicles, which he vehemently denied as opposed to Tadhg Furlong, whose similar disciplinary for an alleged grab on Munster’s Gavin Coombes was thrown out. The disciplinary believed Furlong, and not Wessels and there are so many similarities in their cases.
Furlong got to play the next week while Wessels missed a November tour, lost around R1.5-million in income and was branded a dirty player even though he denied it took place and there was no clear video evidence.
But before we get to what Erasmus has alleged, we need to ask whether there really is a level playing field when it comes to these things.
RUGBY PUNISHES THE MAVERICK
Rugby tends to look down on the maverick, especially one that is successful. Eddie Jones, Michael Cheika come to mind. Erasmus has the ability to call out the elephant in the room while everyone else chooses to ignore it.
But as we all know, you can walk around that elephant in the room, but it does not take away the fact that it is still there.
Ever since that infamous video in the British and Irish Lions series that served up a ban for Erasmus, there has not been a level playing field when he addresses any issues in the game.
And we all know Erasmus is an exceptional rugby brain, and when he bends laws - while acting within them, there is a collective rage that builds across the northern hemisphere.
We saw it with the reaction to the substitution of the front rows during Rugby’s greatest Rivalry and last week in France. If another coach does it, it will be laughed off, but if Rassie does it, it feels like the rest of the rugby world can’t accept it.
RED MEAT FOR RASSIE’S CRITICS
So don’t be surprised by the reaction to Erasmus’ comments - which, when you listen to them at the press conference, for the most part, weren’t worded incorrectly. But for the chasing pack of nations, who are trying to topple the Boks from their rugby plateau, it is more red meat for them to salivate over.
And that’s where the discussion for me took the wrong turn. The moment
Erasmus mentioned that if it wasn’t a mistake, it was perhaps trying to influence the game. The moment he mentioned the word “match-fixing”, it was all the red meat those in the north needed to try and serve another ban on him.
The argument was sound without it and it was a strong one, but it was clouded by the use of the word, and unfortunately that is all that will dominate the headlines from now on.
But we have to ask what is the real problem here? And this could be the question any time World Rugby comes down hard on a coach - is the problem the reaction or is it what he is highlighting? Because if he does have a point, then address it. Shooting the messenger doesn’t clear up the issues in the game, it makes people more cynical, and takes away from the beauty on the field.
RASSIE SPEAKS HIS MIND
The difference between Erasmus and others is that he speaks his mind, while others are cowered into submission. The game needs more clarity, and definitely more consistency, but what we get is the opposite whenever something goes wrong. The referees need to be protected but World Rugby need to realise their actions are making things worse, not better.
The irony is that the discussion started about a hip drop tackle which injured a Fijian player - and not even about the Bok game, but it spiralled from there.
On the disciplinary stuff, Rassie has a right to feel frustrated, as he does when there are countless World Rugby meetings that tell referees and coaches how the game will be reffed, and then when the opposite happens.
It is also World Rugby who cut off the coaches’ rights to have a channel where they can address these instances as well. If Erasmus says there were 16 drop knee tackles, he may be right, but he can only send five clips to World Rugby. At the risk of stating the obvious, how will coaches ever know what direction the game is going unless there is clear and obvious communication between the referees, the governing body and the coaches around the world?
BOKS HAVE THE RIGHT TO BE CYNICAL
Erasmus has the right to be cynical to a disciplinary process around the world which continues to confound, produces some stunningly strange results at times, even though he has to abide by it.
So while the pearl-clutching up north will continue, and World Rugby may act against him, it won’t change the uncomfortable silence about the problems he speaks about. And the more those up north don’t like him, it won’t make it any less true that these things need to be addressed.
That elephant in the room stays there no matter what. Erasmus could choose his words more carefully, and he could be more diplomatic about things, but that is not his way. But punishing the frustration, and not addressing the cause, will makethat elephant grow bigger every day.
Advertisement
