STRIKING IT RICH: Rassie should have used Peyper to lead knee-drop narrative

RASSIE PROVED RIGHT BUT IT GOT LOST
One of the big regrets from a South African rugby viewpoint, if you believe Rassie Erasmus’ possible absence from being part of the Springbok match day for the next six matches is a big blow to their build-up to the Rugby World Cup, is that he didn’t just stick to his initial point.
Advertisement
Meaning what he said after being asked at the fateful Dublin press conference that ultimately led to his six game ban about the likelihood of his team facing the Ireland flyhalf Sam Predergast in Saturday’s match at the AVIVA.
At the time the Irish pivot was under a disciplinary cloud after his tackle in the game against Fiji that led to a Fiji player being injured.
The apparent imbalance when it comes to the findings and punishments meted out to Irish players compared to what South Africans tend to cop for almost exactly the same and similar infringements is a real issue. And as it turned out Rassie was spot on with what he said.
If he had not gone down the road of using the words “match fixing” and talking about match manipulation, which I am afraid is a clear breach of the code and Rassie will know that better than anyone, the clearing of Prendergast by a disciplinary hearing might be what we would be talking about now. Not Rassie’s banning.
We might also be talking about the ridiculous double standards applied to an incident involving Tadgh Furlong when compared to the exact same incident involving the Vodacom Bulls and Bok utility front row forward Jan-Hendrik Wessels.
I can’t imagine wanting to grab someone’s testicles, on the field or off it, but that is what they were both accused of doing. Furlong denied it and they took his word. Wessels denied it and they didn’t take his word. And unfortunately that is seen to be typical, which was what Rassie was driving at, because it does happen all the time.
DHL Stormers prop Neethling Fouche was almost executing a grass-cutting tackle when he was carded for a high and dangerous tackle in a Vodacom URC game a few years back. It was so ridiculous that Stormers coach John Dobson glibly expected him to be available again after appeal, but it didn’t happen. He was suspended for four games.
There is form when it comes to what Rassie was pinpointing in that Dublin press conference. His frustration was understandable. And a day or so after he spoke, he was vindicated - Prendergast was let off.
Are the overseas media who have become so blinded by their hatred for Rassie writing about that? Maybe I am not looking hard enough for I can’t find evidence that they are.
JACO WILL BE POINTING RASSIE IN THE RIGHT DIRECTION
Rassie’s claim that there were 16 knee-drop tackles, a figure he later increased to 17, in the game, three of them yellow card offences and 11 of them offences that should have been penalised, has been glibly accepted by Bok supporters.
There’s actually a lot of grey area, as there is with so much in rugby, with the timing of knees going to ground being disputed by some, and there have been articles written overseas where the forensics have been done and the writers have come up with the line that Rassie was wrong.
Charlie Morgan of The Times claims there were no incidents that Rassie refers to that conform to the sanctions that Rassie felt should have been meted out. My own view is that I spotted some during the game itself, as did one of the Supersport commentators, and I don’t need to go back and check.
My colleague Brenden Nel did a story earlier this week where he ran clips supporting Rassie’s argument. If you haven’t seen that story, check it out.
But ignoring the fact that there is grey area, and unfortunately the line between a correct action and an incorrect one on the rugby field is so fine, there’s another reason I would take Rassie on his word when it comes to the laws.
He has in his management team a man in Jaco Peyper who was the best referee in the world four or five years ago. Jaco would be advising Rassie, as he was earlier in the year when the All Blacks were getting away with skullduggery behind the scenes trying to influence World Rugby on their reading of various aspects of the game.
And my money says that Jaco would be more accurate in his interpretation of the laws and how they are applied than a rugby writer in the UK who may be good at his rugby forensics (and he is, make no mistake) but doesn’t have the experience as a referee that Jaco does.
IF YOU HAVE THE GUY MAKE MORE USE OF HIM
So here’s my problem. I can’t just glibly jump on the bandwagon that many South Africans are on, driven by loyalty and patriotism, and exonerate Rassie for what he said at that press conference.
I have supported Rassie in the past, and did so quite vehemently at times during the RGR tour and series when there was a lot happening behind the scenes that was just patently wrong. Ditto at the 2019 World Cup, when he also had justifiable problems with the refereeing and was in the end vindicated.
The key thing in both of those examples was that I was there for those. I attended the 2019 RWC in Japan, I was closer to the coalface as the saying goes than I am now. Ditto back in August and September, when Brenden and I spent a heck of a lot of time at the Hyde Park Sun, where the Boks were staying.
Okay, the sky bar there is magnificent, but that wasn’t the only reason we were there. You get to speak to people when you are there. You get to understand the frustrations if you are drawn in by the people feeling those frustrations.
I am not sure how many kilometres separate me from the Boks as I write this, but someone told me that there are roughly 11 000 kms separating Cape Town from Dublin. Maybe if I was closer I’d better understand why Rassie went off script, which he most certainly did unless it was his objective to get banned, in which case I have no idea what his endgame might be.
But while acknowledging there is still to be a hearing, and at the moment Rassie is only provisionally suspended, I can’t see how he is going to get off this latest charge. When you become an international coach you sign the code of conduct.
In fact, you do that anywhere you get a job in the professional game. Italy coach Gonzalo Quesado was sanctioned for something far less than what Rassie was sanctioned for back in July so Rassie would have known the perils when he opened his mouth.
Knowing Rassie, I also don’t buy the nonsense that because English is his second language Rassie didn’t know what he was saying. That is insulting the intelligence of someone who is actually a genius. Everything Rassie does is strategic.
As I say, I don’t know what the end game is here. Maybe he’s taking a hit to get World Rugby to take a more critical look at itself, perhaps adjust the ridiculous rule that a coach can only send in five video clips when he or she is unhappy with something.
Make no mistake, when you are dealing with World Rugby you are dealing with an archaic and often out of touch institution. If I was a coach, there are so many laws I would take issue with. Actually, there are just too many of them.
Which is why the idea of the TMO being even more involved terrifies me. Rugby would then be like golf - we’d have a play, then a walk to the next play while the TMO checks everything. This isn’t an attack on golf, but rugby is supposed to be a fast paced sport concluded in less than two hours (actually two hours is too long).
Rassie’s frustrations may be understandable, but he could have expressed them without saying things that bring on the charge of bringing the game into disrepute. And as I believe his biggest crime is his passion for his team and for his country, the way to have avoided that would have been to take the man I mentioned earlier, Jaco Peyper, into that press conference.
Assuming he meant to tackle the knee-drop issue, Peyper would have been the perfect person to speak about that, and as he is a lawyer by trade, he would have put the message across in a way that was more measured and less driven by anger and passion.
Rassie brought Jaco with him when he was driven by a similar agenda during the RGR series and it worked a treat. Felix Jones, who looks like he has become the senior assistant and I would expect to front the post-match press conferences from now on, is also very methodical in how he puts things across and I know he is highly regarded by the overseas media.
In Ireland there are even some pundits predicting he will be the successor to Andy Farrell as the Ireland coach.
RASSIE’S SUSPENSION WILL HURT BUT THERE ARE WAYS TO SOFTEN BLOW
I do find it hard to disagree with those who have written that by doing what he did Rassie has let the team down. To win a World Cup everything has to go off perfectly, not just at the tournament itself but also in the months building up to the event.
Not having Rassie in the coaching box on match days has to hurt, and if it doesn’t then everyone is making a fuss about nothing.
But Rassie was suspended for a long time in the last World Cup cycle, and the Boks ended up retaining the Webb Ellis trophy at the end of it. How?
Well, Jacques Nienaber was the official coach, Rassie was the national director of rugby. Rassie was still the mastermind and Jacques was answerable to him, but as the official coach Jacques was able to carry off the role you’d expect from a coach without Rassie’s absence on match days being noticed.
So if Rassie wants to be proactive in finding a way forward where the Boks continue to thrive without him, is there any law of the game preventing him from moving himself into a different role in those months he is suspended?
It doesn’t have to be a designation that mentions the word ‘wine’ like the position that Brendan Venter filled for a time at Saracens, and he doesn’t even need to put a name to it. Or officially announce someone as the coach.
I am not sure Nienaber wants to come back to the Boks, and if I were a betting person I’d put my money on him popping up at a South African club as his next job before he works for the national team again. But obviously he is the person I would have in mind for the job. It worked last time. And that is not to denigrate Jones, who I think would do a fantastic job in that role too.
SANDPAPERGATE RUMBLES ON
So it has taken me a few days before I actually got to write about Rassie’s suspension. This is my first attempt at it and there’s a reason - it is a sensitive subject, I have backed him in the past, and I know how emotional people get. I also know that my journalistic integrity would be in question if I did not write it like I see it - and this is not a time I can come up for Rassie and consider myself honest.
For emotional fans it is different, but logic has to be applied where I am sitting, and frankly to me Rassie’s outburst on Monday was just bizarre.
But I have had to talk about it in podcasts, and there was a moment earlier this week where I stopped myself in mid conversation. I made out I had forgotten what I was going to say, but the reality was that I just felt I might become tearful.
Who knows why, but as the late James Small would have told you if he was still alive, sometimes when issues touch you it becomes clear that it is nonsense to say that cowboys don’t cry. Having supported Rassie so much in the past, it was hard not to feel emotional when faced with the reality that this time he was definitely in the wrong.
It was not the only time this week those tears hovered. They also hovered when reading the 4 000 word testimony of Cameron Bancroft, the batsman who took the fall along with his captain Steve Smith and vice-captain Dave Warner for the infamous Sandpapergate scandal that rocked cricket during Australia’s test against the Proteas at Newlands in 2018.
There’s not much sympathy for Dave Warner, although it would be good to hear his full side of the story. From the outside, he always seemed to be the driver of the toxic team culture that Bancroft walked into when he first played for Australia.
And of course Smith, although it is clear he wasn’t comfortable with it and didn’t want to know about it, was the captain and ultimately responsible for what happened.
Bancroft was a different issue. Perhaps he looks back now and wonders why he was so weak, but at the time he was new to the team and desperate to fit in.
Most importantly though, it wasn’t just the three players who ended up getting banned by Cricket Australia who were the architects of the sandpaper incident, but the whole team. And those players who kept silent and let those three players get banned when they were all complicit threw those three under the bus.
That is becoming clearer by the day, although as I wrote last week, surely anyone who has played cricket will know that the ball cannot be doctored without the bowlers noticing and being in on it.
The current Australian captain Pat Cummins delivered an impassioned defence in a press conference that extended over an hour, but Piers Morgan has nicknamed him “Pinocchio Pat” and it is hard to disagree with his view. If Australian cricket wants to recover from this the lies just have to stop, the truth has to be told.
And Aussie apologists, such as the guy who interviews the straight talking former Aussie captain Michael Clarke on his podcast, need to start seeing the wood from the trees. Patriotism is a good thing to an extent, but it becomes a bad thing when it blinds people to reality.
And the same should be said to Bok fans. In Rassie we trust, and we should continue to trust him. He’s the best in the world at what he does. But blind trust can just make one look stupid.
Advertisement
